When hiring a brain injury lawyer in New York City, look for traumatic brain injury (TBI) case experience and medical experts. Get the contingency fee terms in writing, and act before your deadline. Most private negligence claims have a 3-year deadline, but a negligence claim against the city generally requires a notice of claim within 90 days.
These steps are harder when an injury affects your memory or you are helping a family member. This guide covers the questions to ask a New York City brain injury lawyer, New York’s fee limits, deadlines by defendant, and who can sign for a relative.
Key Takeaways
- Fees have limits. New York court rules and statutes set contingency fee schedules for injury claims. Compare your retainer’s percentage with the schedule.
- Expenses belong in writing. New York Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5(c) requires written notice of any expenses you owe regardless of outcome. Ask for that clause before you sign.
- Deadlines depend on the defendant. A negligence claim against a city needs notice within 90 days. Most private negligence claims have 3 years, and medical malpractice has 2 years and 6 months.
- A relative can need court authority. A New York court can appoint a guardian for an incapacitated adult when the appointment is necessary.
How Is a Brain Injury Lawyer Different From a General Personal Injury Lawyer?
A brain injury lawyer is a personal injury lawyer who handles traumatic brain injury (TBI) claims, where medical proof is often the main challenge. The CDC says a CT scan is not needed to spot a mild TBI or concussion, but may be used when bleeding is a risk. Ask how the lawyer would prove an injury when the scans look clean.
The defense can test that proof too. After a lawsuit starts, CPLR §3121 lets a party demand a physical or mental examination by a designated physician when your condition is in controversy. Ask how the lawyer prepares clients for that exam.
Questions to Ask at Your First Meeting
Ask these five questions to test the lawyer’s experience, staffing, experts, deadlines, and fee terms. Take notes or bring a relative if memory problems make meetings hard to follow.
- How many traumatic brain injury cases have you handled, and how many went to trial?
- Who will work on my case day to day, and who will appear in court?
- Which medical experts do you expect to use, such as neurologists or neuropsychologists?
- Which deadline applies to my claim, and on what date does it run out?
- Will another firm share the fee, and will you confirm my agreement in writing?
How Much Does a Brain Injury Lawyer Cost in New York?
On a contingency fee, a New York brain injury lawyer is paid a percentage of the recovery, within limits set by court rules and statute. Most injury and wrongful death claims in New York City allow a sliding schedule or up to 33⅓ percent. Medical malpractice has its own schedule.
| Claim and Location | Fee Limit | Computed On |
|---|---|---|
| Most injury and wrongful death claims, First Department (Manhattan, Bronx) | Sliding schedule or up to 33⅓ percent | Net recovery, or gross if your lawyer agrees to pay costs |
| Most injury and wrongful death claims, Second Department (Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island) | Sliding schedule or up to 33⅓ percent | Net recovery |
| Medical malpractice, Judiciary Law §474-a | 30 percent of the first $250,000, 25 percent of the next $250,000, 20 percent of the next $500,000, 15 percent of the next $250,000, and 10 percent above $1,250,000 | Net recovery |
The sliding schedule is 50 percent of the first $1,000, 40 percent of the next $2,000, 35 percent of the next $22,000, and 25 percent above $25,000. Rule 1.5(c) requires a prompt writing with the percentages and the expenses taken from the recovery. It must say whether expenses come out before or after the fee is calculated, and flag any expenses you owe regardless of outcome. Ask for a sample calculation before you sign.
At Frekhtman & Associates, you pay no attorney fee unless we recover for you. We advance case expenses, and the fee and those costs come out of the settlement or verdict.
How Soon Should You Hire a Brain Injury Lawyer in New York?
Hire a lawyer well before your earliest deadline, which depends on who caused the injury.
| Who May Be Responsible | New York Deadline |
|---|---|
| Private party, negligent injury | 3 years under CPLR §214(5). |
| Private doctor or hospital, medical malpractice | 2 years and 6 months from the act or last continuous treatment under CPLR §214-a. |
| City, county, town, village, or school district | Notice of claim within 90 days under General Municipal Law §50-e. Lawsuit within 1 year and 90 days under §50-i. For a death, notice within 90 days of the representative’s appointment and lawsuit within 2 years of the death. |
| Other public defendants, such as NYC Transit or a public hospital | Notice and lawsuit rules can differ, so ask which apply. |
| State of New York | Claim within 90 days, or notice of intention within 90 days and claim within 2 years, under Court of Claims Act §10(3). |
| Someone who assaulted you | Can be 1 year under CPLR §215(3). |
| Negligence that caused a death | The personal representative sues within 2 years of the death under EPTL §5-4.1. |
A court can allow a late notice of claim, but not past the lawsuit deadline, and it weighs factors such as incapacity. CPLR §208 extends some deadlines for a disability because of insanity when the claim accrues, with a 10-year limit. Ask a lawyer whether your brain injury case qualifies.
Who Can Hire a Lawyer for a Relative With a Brain Injury?
Your relative can generally sign the retainer if they understand it and no court order limits their authority. If they cannot, an existing power of attorney may cover the claim, or a court may appoint a representative:
- Guardian: Mental Hygiene Law §81.02 lets a court appoint a guardian when needed for personal needs or property, and the person agrees or is incapacitated.
- Guardian ad litem: A representative a court appoints during an action. Under CPLR §1201, an adult incapable of adequately prosecuting their rights appears through one.
Bring any power of attorney or health care proxy to the first meeting.
Warning Signs When Hiring a Brain Injury Lawyer
- A stranger at the hospital. Rule 7.3(b) generally bars a lawyer from soliciting you in person for paid work. Judiciary Law §480 bars entering a hospital within 15 days after your injury to seek a settlement, release, or statement, unless you agreed in writing at least 5 days before a release or statement. Ask any visitor who they represent.
- A promised dollar figure. Rule 7.1(a) bars false or misleading statements, and a figure with no factual basis can mislead. Ask which facts would raise or lower the value of your claim.
- Pressure to sign today. The Statement of Client’s Rights says you may refuse any fee arrangement you find unsatisfactory. Take the retainer home and read it.
Commonly Asked Questions About Hiring a Brain Injury Lawyer
Can You Sue Someone for Giving You a Brain Injury in New York?
Yes, you can generally sue someone for giving you a brain injury in New York when their negligence or intentional act caused it. Your fault reduces your damages under CPLR §1411, and in car crash cases it can bar recovery. Workers’ compensation usually bars suing your employer or a coworker.
Can You Change Brain Injury Lawyers After Hiring One?
Yes, you can change brain injury lawyers after hiring one, and New York’s client rights statement says court approval may be required in some matters. Your former lawyer may have a claim for services already provided. Read more about switching lawyers during a case.
Can a Mild Brain Injury Support a Claim in New York?
Yes, a mild brain injury can support a claim in New York when you can prove negligence and damages. The CDC says the effects of a mild TBI can still be serious. A car crash claim can need proof of a serious injury under New York’s threshold.
Can a Lawyer Visit You in the Hospital After a Brain Injury?
Yes, your own lawyer can visit you in the hospital after a brain injury. Judiciary Law §480 exempts a person visiting as your attorney or on your attorney’s behalf. Frekhtman & Associates offers home and hospital visits for serious injuries when you are too injured to travel.
Talk With Us When You Are Ready
Contact us for a free case review at (866) 288-9529 or through our contact form.

Our Fight is Your Fight.
Gather your medical records, any insurer letters, and the names of anyone who may be responsible. At Frekhtman & Associates, our NYC personal injury lawyers handle traumatic brain injury claims from six offices in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, and the Bronx.